The Mailbox: Which UDFA stands a chance at making a 53-man roster

Plus, what are realistic expectations for Falcons rookies overall?

Tori McElhaney

FLOWERY BRANCH, Ga. We're in the dog days of summer, y'all, and its a scorcher out there this week. If training camp later this summer is anything close to the near 100 degrees its been the last couple days, I fear for my sanity. But hey, no one said camp life was an easy life. I can assure, it is fun, though. Just have to make sure you're getting that hydration in.

Pro tip: Liquid IV is your friend. Become acquainted before the sun starts zapping you.

But we still have a few weeks before players and coaches report back to ye 'ole Branch for camp. Until then, let's get to some of your dog-days-of-summer questions.

We have content spaces to fill,so submit those Qs hereand I'll chat through them in the upcoming Mailbox installments. Let's goooo.

Steven T. from Ripley, New York

One of the big talking points following the draft was our UDFA's. How many UDFA's do you see having a shot at making the cut to 53?

Love this question, Steven, becauseyou're exactly rightthat there was a lot made about this specific UDFA class for the Falcons in 2025. I actually thought it was one of the most notable of any grouping across the league based on 1) the talent exhibited from the bunch, but also 2) the potential that a couple make the team itself.

I still really like the look and play of Joshua Simon, the tight end out of South Carolina. He caught my eye on the first day of rookie minicamp, and I have continued to appreciate his size (standing at 6-foot-4, 240 pounds) since. He could be an asset in both the run and pass game. He has good hands, but also can take on the physicality needed in outside zone blocking. Yes, you already feel pretty good about Kyle Pitts and Charlie Woerner, but Simon is a piece of depth that I don't think hurts your roster by keeping a spot open for him to slot into in the even something happens to Pitts or Woerner. I see a young player with a lot of upside.

Defensively, I think you still have to pinpoint Cobee Bryant. He was one of the most talked about UDFAs of the entire class. Many were surprised the Kansas cornerback went undrafted all together, and I think it was a big plus that the Falcons were the ones that were able to get him on an off-season roster. The issue with Bryant, though, is the depth the Falcons already have at defensive back, particularly. They brought back a lot of bodies who have already been in this building think Kevin King, Natrone Brooks, Lamar Jackson. They also already have their starters and role players penciled in think A.J. Terrell, Mike Hughes and either Dee Alford, Clark Phillips III or Billy Bowman Jr. at nickel. Is there even room for Bryant on this active roster? I lean towards no, but considering the notoriety he had after the draft, perhaps the Falcons find a way to save him from being picked up by another team following a cut. Worth thinking about.

Zander D. from Port Orange, Florida

What do you believe is a realistic expectation for how these rookies will impact this upcoming year?

Despite this maybe being too lofty, I am going to state it nonetheless: I think the expectation for at least four of the five drafted rookies is to be a starter on defense. Jalon Walker, James Pearce Jr., Xavier Watts and Billy Bowman Jr. all have the capabilities and fit to slot into a starting spot.

Now, I will add the caveat that "starters" within a defensive conversation are seen a bit different than that of their offensive counterparts. Because of the nature of rotating defenses, I often interchange the word "starters" with "significant role players." Most times it is less about who "starts" and more about who takes the most meaningful snaps. Still, I think you're looking at all four of those rookies I listed being meaningful and frequent contributors on this defense early. And therein lies the expectation.

Differing from last year's slate of drafted rookies, I do feel because of the nature of this defensive roster and the capital used on this 2025 draft class that the expectation should be to see them on the field and see them often.

What does actual production for the bunch look like? That can be debated.

I am not ready to put a number on how many sacks Pearce will get, or how many quarterback hits Walker accumulates or the total interceptions Watts comes down with. Putting numerical value behind those expectations is not something I am ready to do yet since I still have not seen any of these rookies working with the first-team in a more live setting. Still, I think a reasonable expectation for these rookies at this point in the offseason is to expect to feel their presence early. I believe that would be a boon for this unit, and would actually work to the numerical value of production if so.

Up Next

Videos

Atlanta Falcons head-to-head debate: How much sleep do you really need? | Ruffled Feathers

Videos

Mailbag: Jalon Walker's role, sleeper impact players & a fan's guide to training camp | Atlanta Falcons Podcast

Videos

Atlanta Falcons 2025 Minicamp Highlights | Top Plays | NFL

Videos

Final thoughts from Falcons' OTAs, early look ahead to training camp | Atlanta Falcons Podcast

Videos

Jessie Bates III, Jalon Walker & other defensive Falcons on positive momentum through OTAs

Videos

Bijan Robinson, Ryan Neuzil & Emory Jones share final thoughts on offensive progress throughout OTAs

Videos

Head Coach Raheem Morris Mandatory Minicamp Day Two Press Conference | Atlanta Falcons

Videos

Kirk Cousins, Drake London & more speak to the media during mandatory minicamp | Press Conference

Videos

Michael Penix Jr. speaks on team growth following day one of Mandatory Minicamp | Press Conference

Videos

Head Coach Raheem Morris Mandatory Minicamp Press Conference | Atlanta Falcons

Videos

Atlanta Falcons 2025 OTA Highlights | Top Moments from Offseason Program

Videos

Falcons legend Michael Vick on coaching in college, Michael Penix Jr. & his favorite Falcons memory

Videos

Bijan Robinson's next step, expectations for Kyle Pitts & more from OTAs | Atlanta Falcons Podcast

Videos

A.J. Terrell Jr. & Divine Deablo are hyped about new-look defense | Press Conferences

Videos

Bijan Robinson, Drake London & others speak on building offensive weapons in OTAs | Atlanta Falcons

Videos

Raheem Morris excited for the effort & work out on field during OTAs| Press Conference

Videos

On the Rise | S5E3 | Bright Futures Begin for Atlanta Falcons 2025 Rookie Class

Videos

Falcons kick off OTAs + Deep dive into realistic rookie expectations | Atlanta Falcons Podcast

Videos

Jessie Bates III, Kaden Elliss & other defensive Falcons reflect on first practice of 2025 OTAs

Videos

Michael Penix Jr., Darnell Mooney & others speak with media following the first practice of OTAs

Videos

Head Coach Raheem Morris OTAs Press Conference | Atlanta Falcons

Videos

D.J. Williams, T.J. Yates & others speak on exciting future for Falcons' offense | Press Conference

Videos

Jerry Gray, Nate Ollie & other Atlanta Falcons defensive coaches speak with media | Press Conference

Videos

Georgia Girls Flag Football / House Resolution 347 Celebration

Videos

Marquice Williams, Zac Robinson & Jeff Ulbrich give updates on offseason program | Press Conferences

Videos

Atlanta Falcons open up OTAs at Flowery Branch training facility | Highlights | NFL

Videos

Breaking down EVERY game of the 2025 Atlanta Falcons schedule | NFL Schedule Release

Videos

Welcome to ATL Kart | Schedule Release 2025

Videos

It's finally HERE! Full Falcons schedule deep dive, hardest stretch & more | Atlanta Falcons Podcast

Videos

Atlanta Falcons Rookie minicamp highlights | First look at 2025 Draft Class | NFL

Videos

Jalon Walker, James Pearce Jr. & other Atlanta Falcons excited to get to work on field | 2025 Rookie Minicamp

Videos

Raheem Morris excited to kick off the 2025 Atlanta Falcons rookie minicamp | Press Conference

Videos

On the Rise | S5E2 | All Access look into the Atlanta Falcons 2025 NFL Draft | NFL

Videos

Atlanta Falcons 2025 rookies arrive to rookie minicamp

Videos

"Juice", Cam Newton & video game bounties: James Pearce Jr. joins Falcons in Focus

Videos

The Tin Man, telepathy & the perfect podcasting voice: Jalon Walker joins Falcons in Focus

Videos

Jerry Gray, Atlanta Falcons defensive staff speak after the 2025 NFL Draft | Press Conferences

Videos

Zac Robinson, T.J. Yates, Kevin Koger & other offensive coaches speak with media | Atlanta Falcons

Videos

Jeff Ulbrich addresses data breach and Shedeur Sanders prank call

Videos

Assistant General Manager Kyle Smith Post-Draft Press Conference | Atlanta Falcons

More Kansas City News

Access More

Sign up for Kansas City News

a daily newsletter full of things to discuss over drinks.and the great thing is that it's on the house!